Nullary vs. DepMap
TLDR
- DepMap (Cancer Dependency Map) is Broad Institute's flagship CRISPR screening dataset across 1000+ cell lines, maintained by Broad and Sanger
- Nullary aggregates DepMap plus other CRISPR databases (BioGRID ORCS, GenomeCRISPR) and surfaces them alongside non-CRISPR negative data
- DepMap is the right choice for deep dives into specific cell-line essentiality screens
- Nullary is the right choice for cross-database CRISPR queries unified with other modalities
What each does
DepMap is a comprehensive CRISPR screening initiative covering essentiality, dependency, and synthetic lethality across ~1000 cancer cell lines. Includes per-guide fold changes, gene effect scores, and dependency annotations. Quarterly releases via depmap.org and bulk download.
Nullary aggregates CRISPR screen results from DepMap, BioGRID ORCS, and GenomeCRISPR into a unified schema, exposing them via MCP alongside non-CRISPR data (small molecules, antibodies, clinical trials).
When to use DepMap directly
- You're doing dependency analysis on specific cancer cell lines
- You need full per-cell-line, per-guide data with all quality metrics
- You need synthetic lethality networks specific to DepMap's methodology
- You're using DepMap-specific analysis tools (CRISPR-RBR, Achilles)
When to use Nullary
- You want CRISPR data alongside other modalities for the same target
- You want failed-guide annotations across multiple CRISPR databases (DepMap + BioGRID ORCS + GenomeCRISPR)
- You want MCP-native access for agent workflows
- You want alerts when new CRISPR failures appear in your target areas
Data overlap
Nullary's CRISPR modality includes DepMap as the primary source. We focus specifically on negative findings: failed guides, non-essential annotations, ancestry-specific failures. DepMap's full positive data isn't included (use DepMap directly for that).
A specific note
In 2024, Broad's analysis found that ~2% of DepMap guides systematically miss their targets in cells from certain ancestries. DepMap subsequently removed those guides from active screens. Nullary preserves the removed-guide annotations as failed_guide records — useful information for understanding screen limitations and avoiding similar issues in your own designs.
Bottom line
Use DepMap for deep cancer-dependency analysis. Use Nullary for cross-database CRISPR queries integrated with other modalities. The CRISPR data in Nullary cites back to DepMap with full provenance.